Bach Re-Invented

Album title:
Bach Re-Invented
JS Bach
Bach: Invention No. 1 in C, BWV772; Invention No. 4 in D minor, BWV775; Invention No. 8 in Fm BWV779; Pritsker: Reinventions; Schnyder: toopART Reinventions; Trapp: Headless Snowman
Simone Dinnerstein (piano); Absolute Ensemble/Kristjan Järvi
Catalogue Number:
BBC Music Magazine
Bach Re-Invented


The paradox of Bach, the great consolidator, is that in his own time he was considered passé, yet to modern ears he sounds challenging, even experimental. Just as he and his Baroque contemporaries ‘borrowed’ material from other composers (and from themselves), the last few decades have seen Bach’s work increasingly plundered by rock groups, jazz musicians and dubstep collagists. I have no objection to this: it’s a measure of how Bach is still widely regarded as relevant and, whatever one might feel about these efforts, the originals abide, unharmed and unbowed.

Gene Pritsker’s piano concerto Reinventions and Daniel Schnyder’s Concerto Grosso toopART Reinventions process fragments of Bach’s material using various popular music styles, though predominantly jazz. It results in the kind of exuberant mélange of classical and non-classical elements that was popular in the ’60s, yet contrasts with the stern modernist approach of pioneering Third Stream efforts. In both works the ensemble playing is vivacious, punchy and commendably tight, and several soloists make engaging contributions, some parts of which are improvised although about 85 per cent of the music is prewritten. For me, though, it is Trapp’s brief, bluesy and exhilarating Snowman (often rather elegant, smeared guitar and all) that sticks in the memory.

Barry Witherden

Bach: Brandenburg Concertos
Bach: Brandenburg Concertos
previous review Article
Berlioz • Liszt
Berlioz • Liszt
next review Article
More about...
We use cookies to improve your experience of our website. Cookies perform functions like recognising you each time you visit and delivering advertising messages that are relevant to you. Read more here