Maxwell Davies: Black Pentecost; Stone Litany

Maxwell Davies
Black Pentecost; Stone Litany
Della Jones (mezzo-soprano), David Wilson-Johnson (baritone); BBC Philharmonic/Peter Maxwell Davies
Catalogue Number:
8.572359 (1993)
BBC Music Magazine
Maxwell Davies: Black Pentecost; Stone Litany

Maxwell Davies has lived for many years in the Orkney Islands, and both works recorded here draw on these northern surroundings – one much more convincingly than the other. Black Pentecost sets prose extracts from George Mackay Brown’s novel Greenvoe, describing how the fictional island of Hellya becomes the site of a huge underground military installation, resulting in the destruction of the local community. (The book turned out to be prophetic of the actual prospect of uranium mining in Orkney, thwarted by a local campaign in which Davies was a prominent figure.) However strong the emotional impulse behind the work’s creation, the musical result is prosaic indeed: the extended orchestral introduction seems to relate only vaguely to the following narrative sections, and these are set for the two solo voices in a strangely generalised manner (apart from the usual Davies device of bad-guy falsetto shrieking to portray the Controller).

Compared to this underpowered and overlong creation, Stone Litany has the impact of a concentrated masterwork. Its setting of runic texts in the prehistoric stone chamber of Maeshowe offers an ultra-virtuoso vocal challenge to which Della Jones rises in impressive style; and the dark-toned orchestral score that unfolds in parallel is a powerful exploration of musical atmospherics, all channelled through a superbly tight-reined formal design. Davies conducts performances of state-of-the-art vividness, although surprisingly some small orchestral mistakes in Stone Litany remain uncorrected.


Malcolm Hayes

JS Bach
JS Bach
previous review Article
Monteverdi: Madrigals, Vol. 2
Monteverdi: Madrigals, Vol. 2
next review Article
We use cookies to improve your experience of our website. Cookies perform functions like recognising you each time you visit and delivering advertising messages that are relevant to you. Read more here