British Clarinet Sonatas, Vol. 1

Album title:
British Clarinet Sonatas, Vol. 1
Clarinet Sonatas
Michael Collins (clarinet), Michael McHale (piano)
Catalogue Number:
CHAN 10704
BBC Music Magazine
British Clarinet Sonatas, Vol. 1

Surprises all the way? Indeed – which might not be what you would expect from this kind of exploration into the byways of British music. Convenient ‘English music’ pigeon-holing is subverted by the presence of Ireland’s Charles Stanford. His Clarinet Sonata sums up the musical climate of its pre-First World War era: while its two outer movements are predictable and super-fluent exercises in Brahms-cloning, its central one, ‘Caoine’ (Lament), searches out a streak of lyrical poignancy that’s both distinctive and memorable.

The short Pastoral, by a Royal College of Music student called Arthur Bliss, is written with a precise ear for sonority. So, too, is John Ireland’s single-movement Fantasy-Sonata of 1943, with its Prokofiev-like punchy rhythms. Bax’s journey through misty-isle territory in his two-movement Sonata is attractive, atmospheric, and (for once) he doesn’t ramble; and the long-spun lines of the first movement of Howells’s Sonata are appealing.

Collins’s clarinet-playing mesmerises the ear: the closing phrase of Stanford’s ‘Caoine’ movement shows what a player in this league can convey in just two quiet notes. Without snatching the limelight, Michael McHale’s accompanying finds a range of keyboard colours in, above all, the works by Ireland and Howells, making their individual sound-worlds seem unexpectedly subtle and rich.

Malcolm Hayes

Shostakovich • Britten • Prokofiev
Shostakovich • Britten • Prokofiev
previous review Article
Songs and Dances from Spain
Songs and Dances from Spain
next review Article
We use cookies to improve your experience of our website. Cookies perform functions like recognising you each time you visit and delivering advertising messages that are relevant to you. Read more here