Janáček; Martinu

A
a
-
Composer(s):
Janáček; Martinu
Works:
Janáček: String Quartets Nos 1 & 2; Martinu: String Quartet No. 3
Performer:
Doric Quartet
Label:
Chandos
Catalogue Number:
CHAN 10848
Performance (Janáček No. 2):
starstarstarstarnostar
Performance (The Rest):
starstarstarstarstar
Recording:
starstarstarstarstar
4
Reviewer:
BBC Music Magazine
Janáček; Martinu

Two generations ago Janáček’s String Quartets were something of a rarity on the concert platform. These days, no self-respecting quartet is without them in their repertoire and the result has been a host of excellent recordings. By any standard, the Doric Quartet’s of Janáček’s First Quartet is magnificent. Their profound understanding of the work probes its dramatic roots – many deriving from The Cunning Little Vixen – and they are not afraid to confront the harshness of some of the instrumentation, notably in the second and third movements. Even more impressive is their flawless control of line, encompassing almost vocal rhetoric in the outer movements against a slowly developing background argument. This is altogether a considered and deeply rewarding account.

Their reading of Quartet No. 2 is not on quite the same level, though it is always engaging, not least in the haunting lullaby of the third movement in which they deploy a captivating sense of timing. Unfortunately, while they show dramatic engagement throughout, the crucial climax of the finale lacks a feeling of true catharsis.

Written hardly more than a year after Janáček’s Second Quartet, Martinu’s Third occupies an entirely different world. Drawn to study in Paris in the 1920s, Martinu was clearly bowled over by the city’s embrace of modernism, with jazz and Stravinsky evident influences. The Doric Quartet slip effortlessly into the driving rhythms of the work while also relishing its occasional ironies.

 

Jan Smaczny
 

Two Disc Review: Franck Chamber Works
previous review Article
Music for Brass Septet, Vol. II
Music for Brass Septet, Vol. II
next review Article
We use cookies to improve your experience of our website. Cookies perform functions like recognising you each time you visit and delivering advertising messages that are relevant to you. Read more here