COMPOSERS: Franck
LABELS: RCA Classical Navigator
WORKS: Symphony in D minor; Symphonic Variations; Le chasseur maudit
PERFORMER: Leonard Pennario (piano); Boston SO/Charles Munch, Boston Pops Orchestra/Arthur Fiedler
CATALOGUE NO: 74321 29256 2 ADD (1957-63)
Not so much golden as silver oldies. Munch’s view of the Franck Symphony is big-boned but coarsely recorded lacking sufficient space and drama. Le chasseur maudit brisker than Cluytens, musically characterful and sonically richer, makes a stronger impression. Pennario’s routine Symphonic Variations, not in Rubinstein’s class, offers little beyond the notes; the piano sound is unlovable. As with other releases in RCA’s Classical Navigator collection, the (unsigned) inlay notes are of a naivety and banality beggaring description. Ates Orga
Franck: Symphony in D minor; Symphonic Variations; Le chasseur maudit
Not so much golden as silver oldies. Munch’s view of the Franck Symphony is big-boned but coarsely recorded lacking sufficient space and drama. Le chasseur maudit brisker than Cluytens, musically characterful and sonically richer, makes a stronger impression. Pennario’s routine Symphonic Variations, not in Rubinstein’s class, offers little beyond the notes; the piano sound is unlovable. As with other releases in RCA’s Classical Navigator collection, the (unsigned) inlay notes are of a naivety and banality beggaring description. Ates Orga
Our rating
3
Published: January 20, 2012 at 3:08 pm