'The most gifted young Polish musicians... master all the technical difficulties of these two scores' by Prokofiev and Weibnberg

A
a
-
Album title:
Prokofiev • Weinberg
Composer(s):
Prokofiev, Weinberg
Works:
Weinberg: Symphony No. 5; Prokofiev: Symphony No. 5
Performer:
Sinfonia Iuventus/Gabriel Chmura
Label:
Warner
Catalogue Number:
9029581271
Performance:
starstarstarstarnostar
Recording:
starstarstarstarstar
4
Reviewer:
BBC Music Magazine
'The most gifted young Polish musicians... master all the technical difficulties of these two scores' by Prokofiev and Weibnberg

The harmonic and textural adventurousness of Weinberg’s powerful Fifth Symphony is indicative of the changing cultural climate in the Soviet Union during the early 1960s. A large-scale four-movement work that moves from a restless opening Allegro moderato and a gloomy Adagio sostenuto to a grotesque Scherzo and an elegiac and emotionally ambiguous Andantino Finale, this is hardly a conventional Socialist Realist symphonic narrative. More specifically, Weinbergwrote the work under the overwhelming impact of hearing the belated premiere of Shostakovich’s rehabilitated Fourth Symphony in 1961. In the same way as in the Shostakovich, Weinberg juxtaposes starkly contrasting musical imagery within specific movements, though the only obvious allusion to the older composer’s work comes in the sinister celesta motif that colours the haunting closing bars. 

In contrast Prokofiev’s Fifth Symphony appears, at least on the surface, to present a much more optimistic demeanour, purportedly capturing a communal sense of relief as the devastating tragedy that had engulfed the Soviet Union during the Second World War was at last coming to an end. At the same time disturbing, even tragic elements are never far from the surface, and these resonances are most effectively projected in the performance from Sinfonia Iuventus and Gabriel Chmura, especially in such passages as the violent climax of the slow movement. 

The orchestra, made up of the most gifted young Polish musicians, certainly master all the technical difficulties of these two scores and Chmura, who has already recorded Weinberg’s Fifth for Chandos, delivers a strong and compelling interpretation of this work. But the Prokofiev is a comparative disappointment, requiring far more fantasy and characterisation to really come alive. 

Erik Levi

Martinů's Symphonies Nos 1-6 conducted by Cornelius Meister
Martinů's Symphonies Nos 1-6 conducted by Cornelius Meister
previous review Article
Vladimir Jurowski gives a 'no-nonsense and sometimes rather brisk approach' to Tchaikovsky's Sleeping Beauty
Vladimir Jurowski gives a 'no-nonsense and sometimes rather brisk approach' to Tchaikovsky's Sleeping Beauty
next review Article
We use cookies to improve your experience of our website. Cookies perform functions like recognising you each time you visit and delivering advertising messages that are relevant to you. Read more here