Piazzolla: Estaciones porteñas

A
a
-
Composer(s):
Duran, Ginastera, Piazzolla
Works:
Piazzolla: Estaciones porteñas; Oblivion; Milonga del ángel; Muerte del ángel; Resurrección del ángel; Tango del ángel; Duran: New Danzon; Contradanza; Ginastera: Milongo
Performer:
The Gryphon Trio
Label:
Analekta
Catalogue Number:
AN 2 9857
Performance:
starstarstarstarnostar
Sound:
starstarstarstarstar
4
Reviewer:
BBC Music Magazine

When Argentinian Astor Piazzolla died in 1992, only a few buffs were familiar with his idiosyncratic hybrid: tango rhythm with assured classical technique; MOR-ballad appeal with combative, Bartók-like dissonance and thrust.

Today the Piazzolla bandwagon, surging along to its 3-3-2 beat, seems unstoppable. Amazon can sell you over 1,400 recordings, and on a summer evening in London he’ll be throbbing soulfully at several outdoor concerts. Smart, stylish, often beautiful exterior; underneath, self-doubt, pain, regret and fear. No wonder Piazzolla’s cask-strength music has such urban appeal in an anxious age.

These discs both give us piano-trio versions of the now-familiar Cuatro estaciones porteñas (Four Seasons in Buenos Aires). No Vivaldi-style twittering birds here: these are psychological, human seasons. The Artemis Project (AP) use their own inventive arrangements; the Gryphon Trio (GT), José Bragato’s ‘more standard’ ones.

They can differ significantly: AP add intros, change registers, and spice things up liberally with those percussive scratches, knocks and string swoops that Piazzolla loved (and swap a viola for violin in ‘Winter’). It notices particularly in ‘Spring’. AP gives us an Angel Suite, four of Piazzolla’s loosely-related ‘angel’ set (Introduction, Tango, Milonga, Death) arranged convincingly and poignantly for string quartet.

GT’s angel selection (Milonga, Death, Resurrection, Tango) use lovely Bragato-style arrangements for piano trio. The Milonga, a Piazzolla signature piece, shows the different approaches: AP’s front-lit, nervy high registers; GT’s rather more resigned, side-lit piano shadows. 

AP include an urgent Fuga y misterio, and a crisp Concierto para quinteto; GT add Oblivion. Interpretatively, AP tend to be faster in the fast sections and slower in the slow, with string solos being a little more intense; GT are a little more laid-back, with a plummier sound.

If you were selecting dancers (not that Piazzolla wrote these to dance to: like Bach, they’re abstracted dance forms, stand-alone music) AP would have the neurotic-thin smoker, vividly made up and tautly gesturing her stockinged legs; GT would get her elder sister with the beautiful sad smile and dewy-eyed hard-luck stories.

Both are superbly played with great style and intense emotion; as with whisky-or-wine, which you prefer depends on taste and circumstance. Rob Ainsley

Brhams: String Quartet No. 1 in C minor
previous review Article
Rachmaninov: Works for cello and piano
next review Article
We use cookies to improve your experience of our website. Cookies perform functions like recognising you each time you visit and delivering advertising messages that are relevant to you. Read more here