Schumann: Piano Quintet & String Quartets

Piano Quintet Op. 44; String Quartets Nos 1-3
Christian Zacharias (piano), Leipzig String Quartet
MDG Gold
Catalogue Number:
307 1610-2
BBC Music Magazine

What a difference a partnership makes. Working with Christian Zacharias the Leipzig Quartet turn out a performance that combines subtlety and strength on the minute expressive and grand architectural planes.

The cortège-like slow movement is rich in romantic hues and half-shades, yet it never loses its sense of the greater emotional ebb and flow. For sheer joie de vivre the Zacharias-Leipzig Scherzo is hard to match (I half expected it to cascade straight over into the finale), nor is there a hint of ‘learned’ display in the finale’s fugal writing, just overflowing creative energy. 

Had the Leipzigers sustained the same levels in the three quartets this would be a set to treasure. But early on in Op. 41 No. 1 the doubts begin to accumulate. Yes, there are echoes of Baroque counterpoint in the slow introduction, but does it have to be so po-faced? (Schumann marks it espressivo.) And in the following Allegro Schumann’s basic dynamics alternate between mezzo forte and piano for a longish stretch.

Unless the markings are radically different in the proposed Urtext version used here, then the Leipzigers’ beefy forte surely misses the mark. 

Certainly they know how to plough a deep furrow, expressively speaking, but often I wish they’d relax the pressure just a bit. A shame because their sense of the music’s originality can be impressive – the brief hushed moderato before the end of Op. 41 No. 1 has never sounded more charged with meaning. They make a powerful case for restoring the tiny introduction to No. 2.

Good sound, though given the stern intensity of the playing a little more distance might have helped. Stephen Johnson



The English Viola
previous review Article
Czech Piano Trios
next review Article
We use cookies to improve your experience of our website. Cookies perform functions like recognising you each time you visit and delivering advertising messages that are relevant to you. Read more here