Songs Without Words: I Giocatori Piano Trio

Album title:
Songs Without Words
Clara Schumann, Mendelssohn, Robert Schumann
Mendelssohn: Piano Trio No. 1 in D minor, Op. 49; Clara Schumann: Piano Trio in G minor, Op. 17 (1846); Robert Schumann: Phantasiestücke, Op. 88
I Giocatori Piano Trio
Catalogue Number:
PH 292034
BBC Music Magazine
Songs Without Words: I Giocatori Piano Trio

One might not be sure why a recording of two piano trios and some Phantasiestücke should be entitled ‘Songs without Words’ – but under this useful umbrella the I Giocatori Piano Trio has assembled a gorgeous programme of Mendelssohn and his friends Robert and Clara Schumann. While the Mendelssohn D minor remains one of the best loved works in the repertoire, the other pieces are relatively unusual – and the standout is Clara’s.

She wrote little music after her marriage to Robert; most pieces that survive were written in her teens. The Trio, though, is a mature work, from 1846, and its quality is exceedingly good. Its four movements are in a conventional enough structure, but her personal voice – closer to Chopin in poised lyrical vein, in some ways, than to Schumann’s obsession and turbulence – is distinctive and absorbing. Her husband’s four Phantasiestücke for trio are also relatively rare; while not necessarily his finest efforts, they are richly expressive and full of ideas.

The I Giocatori Trio is maybe surprisingly named too – it’s Italian for ‘The Players’, but they are not Italian at all. Hendrik and Ludo Ide (respectively violin and cello) and the pianist Hans Ryckelynck offer strong, sympathetic music-making throughout. High points include Ryckelnynck’s apparently effortless sparkle and clarity in the whirling Mendelssohn and the heartfelt intensity of expression that the whole group brings to the C Schumann. A few little quibbles over very occasional moments of insecurity, and a balance in which the violin is sometimes briefly swamped, but on the whole this is an enjoyable and timely release.

Jessica Duchen


Songs Without Words
Songs Without Words
previous review Article
Point and Line: Momo Kodama performs Etudes by Debussy and Hosokawa
Point and Line: Momo Kodama performs Etudes by Debussy and Hosokawa
next review Article
We use cookies to improve your experience of our website. Cookies perform functions like recognising you each time you visit and delivering advertising messages that are relevant to you. Read more here