All products and recordings are chosen independently by our editorial team. This review contains affiliate links and we may receive a commission for purchases made. Please read our affiliates FAQ page to find out more.

Appl and Johnson perform Brahms

Our rating 
4.0 out of 5 star rating 4.0

Brahms: Complete Songs, Vol. 7
Deutsche Volkslieder (selection); Lieder and Gesänge, selections from Opp. 57, 58 and 63
Benjamin Appl (baritone), Graham Johnson (piano)
Hyperion CDJ 33127


This is the seventh in Graham Johnson’s planned series of ten discs covering the entire piano-accompanied vocal works of Brahms, several hundred settings shaped by the varied musical, literary and artistic influences he absorbed over half a century. Johnson has overcome the limitations of the published opus groups and crafted individual recitals designed around a few ‘core’ sets, while still retaining a sense of Brahms’s chronological development.

This thoughtful approach reveals an astonishing stylistic range. It takes in Brahms’s youthful folk-inspired settings, before time- travelling into a stark medieval past, then back into a contemporary sentimental-national idiom, before closing with a generous selection of folksong arrangements. But we are also regularly plunged into steamy eroticism – and few composers evoked desire as searingly as Brahms.

Particularly fine are the three virtuosic settings of poetry by Kopisch from Op. 58, and Schenkendorf from Op. 63. These expansive programmatic miracles betray Brahms’s deep immersion in Schubert’s songs during the 1860s. The gloriously sensual ‘Serenade’ Op. 58 No. 8 would surely persuade any girl to allow her lover to escape the ceaseless rain for an hour!

Johnson is alive to every juicy nuance of the richly detailed accompaniments. And although I was occasionally distracted by Appl’s closed vowels, which sometimes robbed the poetry of its immediacy, he brings many beautiful details to his reading.


Natasha Loges