All products and recordings are chosen independently by our editorial team. This review contains affiliate links and we may receive a commission for purchases made. Please read our affiliates FAQ page to find out more.

A ‘satisfying and unusual’ recording of violin works by Prokofiev

Our rating 
5.0 out of 5 star rating 5.0

Violin Concerto No. 2; Solo Violin Sonata in D; Five Melodies; The Love for Three Oranges – March; Andante
Rosanne Philippens (violin), Julien Quentin (piano); St Gallen Symphony Orchestra/Otto Tausk
Channel Classics CCS 39517


Quite a double whammy, this. Not only is the programme as a whole both satisfying and unusual, but also Rosanne Philippens’s startling partnership with the excellent St Gallen Symphony Orchestra and Otto Tausk puts her Prokofiev Second Violin Concerto right at the top of the many recent recordings – her (Dutch) compatriot Janine Jansen’s included. This most natural of concerto recordings was made in St Gallen’s Tonhalle, which must be very fine on this evidence. Orchestra and conductor extend their remarkable probing of Prokofiev’s sparer, mostly lower-end sonorities with a lugubrious envoi, the orchestral Andante of 1934. This was Prokofiev’s returning of the movement previously adapted from his student symphony in his Fourth Piano Sonata to orchestral guise. Solo timbres shine in the gloom; lower brass work is outstanding.

Philippens also turns in the most poetic and characterful performances of the late, D major Violin Sonata – originally intended by Prokofiev for a whole department of unison student violins – and the Five Melodies transcribed from the Songs without Words. As in the Concerto, Philippens keeps the right quiet dynamics, shrouded in sphinx-like atmosphere, and she’s limpidly partnered by pianist Julien Quentin. The headlong if always focused excitement of the Concerto’s dance-of-death finale is matched by the more straightforward exuberance of the March from The Love for Three Oranges arranged by Heifetz.

Read more reviews of the latest Prokofiev recordings

David Nice


Listen to an excerpt from this recording here.