Beethoven
Piano Sonatas, Opp 109, 110 & 111
Mitsuko Uchida (piano)
Decca 4872064 73 mins
Beethoven was both profoundly deaf and in rotten health when he was working on the Missa solemnis and the Diabelli Variations.
In such circumstances it still seems preposterous that he should at the same time have been able to create his last three piano sonatas, which would stand forever as the peak of classical pianism. You could describe it as a giant internal debate, or a musical guide to heaven, earth and Hades; so much is going on intellectually, on so many levels, that no neat generalisation can encompass it.
Time was when a seamlessly consecutive performance of these three works was seen as a risky thing to stage; for most would-be mountaineers, just playing the notes is challenge enough. Mitsuko Uchida played it to universal acclaim at both the Southbank Centre and Wigmore Hall, but this album – with an exceptionally illuminating commentary by Misha Donat – offers something different.
'No short review can communicate the sheer excitement'
Pervading the shocks and surprises of Op. 109, followed by the crazy rule-breaking in Op. 110, and by the trumpets and celestial whispers of Op. 111, there is a serene calm, as though we are being led by the hand with wonderful fidelity to Beethoven’s intentions. When he tells us ‘Ermattet, klagend… poi a poi di nuovo vivente’ (exhausted, lamenting, then little by little, coming back to life), Uchida follows him to the letter, running the gamut of moods and effects from swooning lyricism to ferocious aggression.
No short review can communicate the sheer excitement of this performance, with its frequently Bachian echoes. While Op. 109 lays out the territory with spinning grace, Op. 110 takes us to the heart of ever deeper mysteries, and Op. 111 becomes an ecstatic meditation leading us to heaven on the wings of an airy lattice-work of trills.

