COMPOSERS: Milhaud
LABELS: Naxos
WORKS: Service Sacré
PERFORMER: Yaron Windmueller (baritone), Rabbi Rodney Mariner (reader); Prague Philharmonic Choir, Czech PO/Gerard Schwarz
CATALOGUE NO: 8.559409
Schwarz also steers a convincing course through Milhaud’s Service Sacré. Much of this large-scale 1940s work is gentle and contemplative with only a few moments of dramatic intensity. As with so much by this enormously prolific composer, Service Sacré is fluent and expertly scored but strikes me as lacking in truly memorable material. Nonetheless the style is distinctive and recognisable, and operates at a much higher level of musical sophistication than the relatively anodyne Sacred Service for the Sabbath Eve as set by the Italian émigré Castelnuovo-Tedesco. The sincerity of his message is not in question, but too much of the music in this and other works on this disc is dull and predictable, with an over-reliance on imitation to spin out the musical argument. This impression is compounded by a rather lacklustre performance from the London Chorus who sound distinctly unengaged by what they are singing.
Milhaud: Service Sacré
Schwarz also steers a convincing course through Milhaud’s Service Sacré. Much of this large-scale 1940s work is gentle and contemplative with only a few moments of dramatic intensity. As with so much by this enormously prolific composer, Service Sacré is fluent and expertly scored but strikes me as lacking in truly memorable material. Nonetheless the style is distinctive and recognisable, and operates at a much higher level of musical sophistication than the relatively anodyne Sacred Service for the Sabbath Eve as set by the Italian émigré Castelnuovo-Tedesco.
Our rating
2
Published: January 20, 2012 at 3:51 pm
Share this article
Exclusive U.S. Offer
Try a BBC Music Magazine subscription and get free delivery from the UK!
Subscribe Now!
