All products and recordings are chosen independently by our editorial team. This review contains affiliate links and we may receive a commission for purchases made. Please read our affiliates FAQ page to find out more.

Tormento d’amore (Ian Bostridge)

Ian Bostridge (tenor); Cappella Neapolitana/Antonio Florio (Warner Classics)

Our rating 
4.0 out of 5 star rating 4.0

Tormento d’amore
Arias by Caresana, Cavalli, Cesti, Sartorio, Stradella, Vinci et al
Ian Bostridge (tenor); Cappella Neapolitana/Antonio Florio
Warner Classics 9029503707   68:51 mins


Recently Ian Bostridge has produced recordings of Schubert, Respighi and songs by Noël Coward – all intelligent and notable productions but quite some way away from early operatic arias. His last foray into this area was the title role of Monteverdi’s Orfeo in 2005, and in some ways this disc may be considered a belated extension of that exploration. It sets out to demonstrate that the tenor voice had an important role on the early stage, and it also takes us on a journey from the beginnings of opera in Venice (Cavalli, Stradella, Cesti) to Naples (Caresana, Provenzale, Fago) and then back to Venice again (Vinci, Legrenzi and Vivaldi).

Bostridge is at his best in those pieces requiring technically adroit command and intelligent poise. He floats through the busy roulades signifying the turning wheel of Fortune in Caresana’s ‘Tien ferma Fortuna’, and in Cesti’s ‘Berenice, ove sei?’ he eases his voice perfectly into the complex harmonies. Sometimes he concentrates on the lyricism or pushy bravura required at the expense of more subtle characterisation using the voice. The bravura is excellent in Vinci’s ‘Se il mio paterno’, but in his blood-curdling ‘Gelido in ogni vena’ we miss the dark, rasping savagery which can only be produced by surrendering a little of the impressive technique. The sunlight returns at the end when Bostridge serves up a wonderfully captivating performance of the traditional Neapolitan song, ‘Lu cardillo’ (made famous by, of all people, Joan Baez who in her version charmingly murders the Italian).

Anthony Pryer

More reviews

Iván Fischer conducts Mahler’s Symphony No. 3

Haydn’s Symphonies Nos 53, 64 and 96 performed by The Oregon Symphony, conducted by Carlos Kalmar

Daniel Barenboim: Hommage à Boulez

Edward Gardner conducts Elgar’s Symphony No. 1

Semyon Bychkov conducts the Vienna Philharmonic in a performance of Shmidt’s Symphony No. 2 and R Strauss’s Dreaming by the Fireside


Arturo Toscanini conducts performances of Mendessohn and Wagner