A band, at its best, is a volatile crucible of creative talent: a delicate ecosystem where egos, temperaments, and artistic visions collide and, hopefully, coalesce into something extraordinary.
But this intense reliance on each other – financially, emotionally, and artistically – often makes harmonious coexistence a near impossibility. Beneath the glittering façade of sold-out stadiums and platinum records, a band is still just a group of people in close quarters, and human dynamics are rarely simple.
Disagreements over money, musical direction, substance abuse, personality clashes, or simply being deemed 'not good enough' become magnified under the spotlight, making firings almost an inevitable rite of passage. These aren't just job losses; they are often traumatic, public divorces that reshape careers, redefine legacies, and leave indelible scars on all involved.
Here are 15 of rock's most notorious terminations of employment.
1. Pete Best – The Beatles (1962)
The most infamous firing in rock history occurred just as The Beatles stood on the precipice of superstardom. Pete Best had drummed for the group through their gruelling Hamburg residencies, but in 1962, manager Brian Epstein delivered a brutal dismissal. While producer George Martin questioned Best’s studio timing, persistent rumours also suggested a green-eyed monster was at play.
Best was conventionally handsome, often receiving the loudest screams from female fans. Legend suggests that John, George and (in particular) Paul felt upstaged by his movie star looks and moody charisma. Ultimately, Best's perceived lack of technical proficiency provided the professional excuse to replace him with the more compatible Ringo Starr (and also renowned as the best drummer in Liverpool at the time).
2. Ozzy Osbourne – Black Sabbath (1979)
After a decade of defining heavy metal, Ozzy Osbourne's increasingly erratic behaviour and severe substance abuse became too much for Black Sabbath. While his wild stage antics (basically a combination of manic energy and eerie, staring-eyed intensity) had fuelled Sabbath's legend, his unreliability in the studio and his inability to remember lyrics led the band to a stark choice. Tony Iommi, Geezer Butler, and Bill Ward fired their iconic frontman, initiating a chaotic period for both Ozzy and the band, though it ultimately launched his wildly successful solo career.
3. Andy Rourke – The Smiths (1986)
This dismissal was as melancholic and dramatic as a Smiths song. Bassist Andy Rourke, struggling with heroin addiction, was famously informed of his sacking via a note Morrissey left on his car windscreen: 'Andy, you have left The Smiths – goodbye, good luck, Morrissey'. Although he was reinstated shortly after following a band meeting, the incident highlighted the tension within the band and Morrissey's sometimes cold communication style. It remains a poignant, almost poetic, example of rock 'n' roll cruelty.
- We listed The Smiths as one of the greatest bands to fail to break America
4. Jimi Hendrix – Little Richard's Band (1965)
In 1965, long before the world knew him as a psychedelic icon, Jimi Hendrix was plain old Jimmy James, a sideman in Little Richard’s Upsetters. Little Richard, a man of immense ego, demanded absolute discipline and a spotlight that shone on him alone. Hendrix’s flashy presence – which included wearing flamboyant ruffles, playing the guitar with his teeth, and performing wild behind-the-back solos – was seen as a direct challenge to Richard’s authority.
After Hendrix repeatedly missed tour buses and continued to upstage the 'Architect of Rock 'n' Roll' with his sheer virtuosity and peacocking style, Richard finally fired him, famously declaring: 'I am the King of Rock 'n' Roll, and you're just a guitar player.'
5. Lol Tolhurst – The Cure (1989)
Founding member and childhood friend of Robert Smith, Lol Tolhurst’s struggles with alcoholism led to his dismissal from The Cure during the recording of Disintegration. While he had transitioned from drums to keyboards, his contributions dwindled, and his personal issues became untenable. Smith, famously loyal, made the difficult decision to remove him, leading to a public legal battle before they eventually reconciled years later. It was a painful end to a lifelong musical partnership.
6. Brix Smith – The Fall
Mark E. Smith was less a bandleader and more a dictator. The Fall was infamous for its revolving door of members, with Smith routinely firing (and sometimes re-hiring) musicians with brutal efficiency, often mid-tour. One notorious example was Brix Smith, his then-wife, who he fired twice. These dismissals weren't just about musical differences; they were part of Smith's philosophy of constant change and asserting total control over his artistic vision, no matter the human cost.
7. Courtney Love – Faith No More (1981-1982)
Before Hole and her global fame, Courtney Love had a brief, tumultuous stint as the lead singer for Faith No More. She was reportedly fired due to her erratic behavior and her perceived lack of "commitment" to the band's musical direction. The band members found her too chaotic and unfocused for their developing sound. Love herself stated she was 'bored' and uninterested in their funk-metal fusion, making it a mutual, if swift, parting.
8. Dave Mustaine – Metallica (1982)
Dave Mustaine was a foundational architect of Metallica’s razor-sharp thrash sound, but his tenure ended abruptly in 1983 due to volatile 'mean drunk' behaviour and physical altercations with frontman James Hetfield. After a physical fight over Mustaine’s dog, the band woke him up, handed him a bus ticket, and fired him on the spot.
This cold dismissal birthed a legendary 40-year rivalry; Mustaine formed Megadeth with the singular, vengeful goal of being faster and heavier than his former bandmates. While Metallica became global icons, Mustaine’s technical brilliance and lingering resentment fuelled a 'Big Four' arms race (alongside Slayer and Anthrax) that defined the thrash metal genre.
9. Danny Kirwan – Fleetwood Mac (1972)
Fleetwood Mac's early years were riddled with lineup changes, but Danny Kirwan's firing was particularly dramatic. The gifted guitarist descended into alcoholism and mental health issues. During an American tour, he refused to perform and then smashed his guitar before a gig, destroying the band’s equipment. Mick Fleetwood, out of options, fired him on the spot, marking another sad chapter in the band's notoriously troubled history.
- Love Fleetwood Mac's Rumours? Try these 11 forgotten West Coast classics next
- The album that almost bankrupted Fleetwood Mac
Kirwan is remembered, among other things. for his key role in the band's early hit 'Albatross'. He contributed the counterpoint harmony in the song's middle section, and its writer Peter Green admitted he would never have completed 'Albatross' without Kirwan's input.
10. Brian Jones – The Rolling Stones (1969)
As the founder and original visionary of the Rolling Stones, Brian Jones’s multi-instrumental genius provided the band’s most exotic colours, from the haunting sitar on 'Paint It, Black' to the ethereal marimba on 'Under My Thumb'. However, by 1969, a debilitating cocktail of drug dependency and spiralling paranoia – exacerbated by a feeling of displacement within his own band – left him a ghost of his former self.
Jones's declining mental health made him a liability in the studio, leading Mick Jagger and Keith Richards to fire him at his Cotchford Farm estate. Barely a month later, Jones was found dead at the bottom of his swimming pool, aged 27. Without him, the Stones shed their psychedelic experimentation, pivoting into a leaner, riff-heavy rock machine that conquered the 1970s but lost its original avant-garde spark.
11. Syd Barrett – Pink Floyd (1968)
By 1968, Syd Barrett’s heavy psychedelic use and deteriorating mental health transformed him from Pink Floyd’s visionary leader into an erratic liability. He would often go catatonic on stage or play a single chord for hours, leaving the band unable to function. The 'firing' was famously informal: as they drove to a gig in Southampton, someone simply asked, 'Shall we pick up Syd?' and the answer was, 'No, let’s not bother.'
They initially hoped to keep him as a non-touring songwriter – a Brian Wilson-type figure – but Syd’s tragic disconnect from reality made any collaboration impossible, forcing Pink Floyd to evolve without their founder.
- We included Syd Barrett in our rundown of rock's brilliant but tortured artists
12. Mick Jones – The Clash (1983)
In 1983, Joe Strummer and Paul Simonon fired Mick Jones, citing his unreliability and drifting musical tastes. In reality, the creative tension between Strummer’s street-punk purism and Jones’s fascination with hip-hop and dance music had become toxic. The dismissal was a fatal blow; without Jones’s melodic genius and arrangement skills, the band collapsed into the disastrous Cut the Crap (definitely one of those albums where you can hear a band falling apart) and disbanded. By cutting out their musical heart, The Clash effectively committed artistic self-sabotage.
13. Paul Di'Anno – Iron Maiden (1981)
Iron Maiden were on the cusp of global fame, but frontman Paul Di'Anno's wild partying and substance abuse were derailing their progress. Unable to handle the grueling touring schedule and unreliable in the studio, he was fired. Bruce Dickinson was brought in as his replacement, and the band exploded onto the world stage. Di'Anno's dismissal was a harsh, but necessary, move that propelled Maiden to superstardom.
14. Peter Criss – KISS (1980)
Peter Criss’s decline began around 1978, accelerated by a car accident and a spiraling cocaine addiction that shattered his timing. By 1979’s Dynasty tour, he was actively sabotaging shows – intentionally slowing tempos or stopping mid-song to spite frontman Paul Stanley. The situation peaked when Criss attacked Gene Simmons with a broken champagne bottle backstage.
In 1980, Stanley, Simmons, and a reluctant Ace Frehley held a formal vote to fire him. Though Criss claimed he quit to preserve his 'Catman' pride, the ballot made his dismissal official.
15. Glenn Cornick – Jethro Tull (1970)
As a founding member, Glenn Cornick’s melodic, busy basslines were essential to Jethro Tull’s early blues-rock success. However, the culture clash became untenable by 1970. While Cornick fully embraced the sex, drugs, and rock 'n' roll lifestyle of a touring musician, frontman Ian Anderson was a teetotaling, highly disciplined perfectionist.
Fed up with Cornick’s late-night partying and perceived lack of focus during the Benefit tour, Anderson formally dismissed him. This firing consolidated Anderson’s absolute control, shifting the band toward the dense, scholarly prog rock of Aqualung.
Pics Getty Images
