Even the greatest rock legends stumble.
And when they do, the results can be fascinating, bizarre, or just plain awful. Whether driven by experimentation, ego, exhaustion, or label pressure, some of the most revered artists in music history have released albums that left critics scratching their heads and fans wondering what went wrong. These aren’t just minor missteps or underrated gems: they’re the albums that tested patience, sparked confusion, and, in some cases, were outright disowned by their creators.
Take Lou Reed’s Metal Machine Music, a relentless screech of guitar feedback that’s still debated as high art or high-level trolling. Or David Bowie’s Never Let Me Down, an album so uninspired he later asked for it to be reworked. From Neil Young’s rockabilly head-scratcher Everybody's Rockin' to Queen’s funk misfire Hot Space, these records mark the weird, wild detours in otherwise stellar careers.
And yet, there’s something oddly compelling about these infamous outliers. They remind us that even rock’s biggest icons are human – prone to risk, reinvention, and the occasional creative trainwreck. So here they are: 11 of the most unpopular, misunderstood, or downright maligned albums by truly great rock acts. Approach with caution… or curiosity.
1. Lou Reed Metal Machine Music (1975)
Lou Reed’s most infamous and confrontational work, Metal Machine Music is a double album of relentless guitar feedback and distortion, unleavened by any melody or rhythm. Hailed by some as avant-garde genius and dismissed by others as an elaborate joke or contractual protest, it's virtually unlistenable for most. Yet its abrasive, uncompromising nature earned cult status, influencing noise, industrial, and experimental artists for decades. Love it or loathe it, it’s unforgettable.
2. David Bowie Never Let Me Down (1987)
Scary Monsters and Let's Dance apart, David Bowie's 1980s fell some way short of his incredible, trailblazing 1970s. Never Let Me Down is widely considered his creative low point: a slick, overproduced collection that lacks the innovation and charisma that defined his earlier work. Struggling to find artistic direction in the MTV era, Bowie leaned into generic rock and uninspired songwriting. Even he later admitted disappointment, calling it a failure. Despite flashes of potential, it’s often cited as the moment Bowie’s genius dimmed –temporarily.
3. The Beatles Yellow Submarine (1969)
Technically a soundtrack, this is the only Beatles release that feels like filler. With only four new songs (two of which were George Harrison leftovers) and an entire side dedicated to George Martin's orchestral score, it lacks the cohesive genius of their major albums. While 'Hey Bulldog' is a fierce rocker, the album as a whole feels like a minor footnote in an otherwise flawless discography, released primarily to satisfy the film's requirements.
4. Pink Floyd A Momentary Lapse of Reason (1987)
The first album without Roger Waters, this record often feels more like a David Gilmour solo project than a true Pink Floyd statement. Desperate to prove they could survive without Waters' conceptual leadership, the band leaned heavily on 80s gated reverb and session musicians. While the exhilarating 'Learning to Fly' and emotive 'On the Turning Away' are classics, much of the album lacks the atmospheric depth and lyrical bite that defined their 70s peak, feeling strangely corporate by comparison.
5. Bob Dylan Self Portrait (1970)
Self Portrait (1970) baffled fans and critics alike. A sprawling double album filled with covers, odd choices, and lo-fi performances, it felt deliberately unfocused and disengaged. Coming off a string of groundbreaking records, Bob Dylan seemed to be dismantling his own myth. Critics panned it – famously prompting “What is this s***?” from Rolling Stone's Lester Bangs. Whether a prank or a purge, Self Portrait marked Dylan’s most confounding and least cohesive artistic statement.
6. Rolling Stones Dirty Work (1986)
One of the Rolling Stones’ most troubled and least loved albums. Recorded amid internal strife (especially between Mick Jagger and Keith Richards), Dirty Work feels disjointed and joyless, with glossy ‘80s production masking uninspired material. Charlie Watts was largely absent, and Ron Wood helped hold things together. Despite a few flashes of energy, Dirty Work lacks the swagger and soul that made the Stones legendary. It's their creative low point.
7. Neil Young Everybody's Rockin' (1983)
We were going to pick 1982's vocoder-fuelled cod-Kraftwerk album Trans, but there's a strange charm to that album. There's little to love, though, about Everybody’s Rockin’, Neil Young’s baffling detour into retro rockabilly. Released during a turbulent period with Geffen Records, it was seen by many as a deliberate provocation rather than a sincere musical statement. Clocking in at under 25 minutes, it felt like a parody of itself. Critics and fans were largely unimpressed – Young even faced a lawsuit from his label for making 'unrepresentative' music.
8. The Clash Cut the Crap (1985)
The much-maligned final album by The Clash – a band already splintered and reeling from key departures. Without Mick Jones and Topper Headon, and under the heavy-handed control of manager Bernie Rhodes, the album suffers from clunky songwriting, synthetic production, and an overuse of shouted gang vocals. Despite Joe Strummer’s presence, it lacks the fire and conviction of earlier work, making it a disappointing and chaotic end to a legendary band.
9. Metallica St. Anger (2003)
Infamous for its 'trash can lid' snare drum sound and the complete absence of guitar solos, St. Anger was the sound of a band in therapy. While the raw, ugly energy was a deliberate choice to capture their internal turmoil, the songs are overlong and the production is physically difficult to listen to. It remains the most divisive entry in their catalogue, a well-meaning attempt at honesty that resulted in a sonic anomaly.
10. Genesis Calling All Stations (1997)
After Phil Collins departed, Genesis's remaining founder members (keyboardist Tony Banks and guitarist Mike Rutherford) recruited Ray Wilson for one final studio outing. The result is a dour, leaden record that lacks the pop-craft of the Collins era and the whimsical imagination of the Gabriel years. It is 'Genesis-lite', a grey and unmemorable collection of songs that lacked the chemistry required to sustain the band's legendary name into a new decade.
11. The Who It's Hard (1982)
1982's It’s Hard is often cited as one of The Who’s weakest efforts: a by-the-numbers rock album that lacks the energy and innovation of their peak years. Released during a period of creative fatigue, it marked their final studio album with drummer Kenney Jones. Despite moments of promise (Eminence Front stands out), much of the record feels uninspired and sterile, a far cry from the raw power that once defined The Who. By the way, if you're looking for a better Who-related album from this era, we recommend Pete Townshend's '82 effort All the Best Cowboys Have Chinese Eyes.
12. Led Zeppelin In Through the Out Door (1979)
Led Zep's final studio album proper is also their most divisive: an experimental detour shaped largely by John Paul Jones and Robert Plant, as Jimmy Page and John Bonham struggled with personal issues. Synth-heavy and mellow in tone, it lacked the hard-rock punch fans expected. Though commercially successful, critics found it uneven and unfocused. While not without charm, it signaled a band drifting from its thunderous roots.
13. Black Sabbath Forbidden (1995)
The final album of the Tony Martin era is a bizarre attempt to modernize the Sabbath sound by bringing in Ernie C (of Body Count) to produce. It features a guest spot from Ice-T and a thin, weak production that neuters Tony Iommi’s legendary riffs. It is the furthest the band ever drifted from their heavy, doom-laden roots, sounding like a band that had completely lost its identity in the face of changing 90s trends.
14. The Doors Other Voices (1971)
Attempting to carry on just months after Jim Morrison’s death was a bold move, but ultimately a misguided one. Ray Manzarek and Robby Krieger took over vocal duties, but without Morrison’s poetic charisma and baritone weight, the band sounded like a high-end Doors cover act. The songs are competent jazz-rock, but they lack the danger and 'shamanic' energy that made The Doors essential.
15. Queen Hot Space (1982)
A harsh inclusion, perhaps, as it has legions of admirers. Nonetheless, Hot Space stands as Queen’s most controversial album – a bold pivot into funk, disco, and synth-pop that alienated many longtime fans. Following the global success of 'Another One Bites the Dust', the band leaned hard into dance influences, sidelining their signature rock sound. While tracks like 'Under Pressure' (with David Bowie) shine, much of the album felt jarring and out of step with the band's trajectory.
16. U2 Pop (1997)
Pop (1997) was U2’s ambitious attempt to merge rock with cutting-edge electronica, techno, and dance music. Despite bold production and thematic depth, the album felt overcooked yet underdeveloped, as the band rushed to meet a tour deadline. Critics were mixed, and many fans were left cold by the glossy experimentation. Though it has its defenders, Pop is widely viewed as a rare misfire in U2’s otherwise towering discography.
17. Van Morrison Latest Record Project, Vol. 1 (2021)
Van Morrison’s most polarizing release: a sprawling double album filled with grumpy diatribes, anti-establishment rants, and conspiracy-tinged lyrics. Gone is the poetic mysticism of his classic work, replaced by bitterness and frustration. Critics widely panned the album, calling it self-indulgent and tone-deaf. While musically competent, its message alienated many longtime fans, marking a sharp and unwelcome turn in Morrison’s storied career.
18. Emerson, Lake and Palmer Love Beach (1978)
Emerson, Lake & Palmer’s last album (for 14 years) is also their most derided: an awkward attempt at radio-friendly rock that abandoned the band’s trademark complexity and bombast. With its infamous shirtless cover and lightweight songs, it felt like a commercial compromise rather than a true creative effort. Recorded under pressure to fulfill a contract, the album lacked passion and cohesion, making it a disappointing and embarrassing chapter in ELP’s prog rock legacy.
19. Aerosmith Rock in a Hard Place (1982)
Without guitarists Joe Perry and Brad Whitford, this isn't really an Aerosmith album; it's Steven Tyler and a group of substitutes. Plagued by Tyler’s deepening drug addiction and internal squabbles, the record is a messy, incoherent attempt at hard rock that lacks Tyler and Perry's legendary 'toxic twins' chemistry. Aside from the minor hit 'Lightning Strikes', it is a bleak document of a band on the verge of total collapse.
Top pic: Pink Floyd circa A Momentary Lapse of Reason, 1987.
Pic Getty Images
