Some albums just don’t seem to fit among their peers.
Every great band builds a sound, a style, a set of expectations – and then, once in a while, they throw all of it out the window. The result is an “outlier album”: a record that doesn’t sound like anything else in their catalogue. Sometimes it’s a glorious experiment, sometimes it’s a baffling misfire, and sometimes it’s both at once. But it’s always fascinating.
Think of it as the moment an artist swerved off the main road and ended up somewhere completely unexpected – psychedelia from the Stones, synths from Neil Young, or a sprawling art-rock opus from Fleetwood Mac when the world wanted Rumours II. These records stand out precisely because they don’t belong. They break the flow of a discography, showing us what happens when musicians get restless, bored, or just plain reckless.
Some outliers eventually become cult favourites, decades ahead of their time. Others remain notorious cautionary tales, filed under “what were they thinking?” Either way, they capture the chaos and curiosity that make rock history so endlessly entertaining.
Here are 11 albums like nothing else in their bands’ discography.
1. Bob Dylan Self Portrait (1970)
Bob Dylan’s first album of the 1970s baffled fans and critics alike. Instead of the poetic intensity he was revered for, Dylan offered a sprawling double album of covers, odd originals, and schmaltzy arrangements. Seen as a deliberate act of self-sabotage – a way to dismantle his own legend – it stood in stark contrast to his ’60s masterpieces. Over time, though, it’s been partly reassessed as a bold, if eccentric, experiment.
Key track: All the Tired Horses
2. Jethro Tull Under Wraps (1984)
A curious outlier in the Tull discography. Embracing synth-driven arrangements and drum machines, Ian Anderson’s signature flute takes a back seat, replaced by a slick, electronic sheen. The album polarised fans, as the band traded their folk-prog rock complexity for 1980s tech-pop aesthetics. Its themes – espionage, secrecy, and modern paranoia – add a conceptual layer, making it a bold, if divisive, experiment.
Key track: Under Wraps 1
3. Fleetwood Mac Tusk (1979)
Tusk (1979) is an audacious outlier. Following the polished mega-success of Rumours, the band embraced experimental textures, post-punk influences, and Lindsey Buckingham’s obsessive production. The sprawling double album is adventurous, uneven, and full of sonic risk-taking, from tribal percussion to fragmented arrangements. Initially bewildering fans and costly to produce, Tusk has since been celebrated for its daring creativity and defiance of commercial expectation.
Key track: Tusk
4. The Beatles Let It Be (1970)
Let It Be is the Beatles’ strange swan song – recorded amid acrimony, half live-in-the-studio experiment, half posthumous patchwork. Conceived as a 'back-to-basics' project after Sgt. Pepper’s grandeur, it morphed into tense sessions documented on film, then was controversially overproduced by Phil Spector. With its fractured energy, stripped-down tone, and uneasy mix of brilliance and bitterness, it stands apart from the band’s otherwise meticulously crafted catalogue.
Key track: The Long and Winding Road
5. Black Sabbath Technical Ecstasy (1976)
After defining the 'doom' aesthetic, Black Sabbath inexplicably traded their soot-stained riffs for polished hard rock and symphonic flourishes. The addition of prominent synthesizers and even a Beatles-esque pop ballad sung by drummer Bill Ward marked a radical departure from their occult roots. It sounds shockingly 'bright' and commercial compared to the crushing weight of their earlier work, representing a band struggling to find their identity amidst the changing tides of the late Seventies.
Key track: It's Alright
6. Kraftwerk Kraftwerk (1970)
Long before they donned robot suits and mastered the electronic pulse, Kraftwerk’s debut was a sprawling, organic krautrock experiment. Featuring flutes, violins, and live drumming, it feels more like a commune jam than a digital factory. This dusty, psychedelic relic is almost unrecognizable to fans of their later clinical synth-pop. It serves as a fascinating glimpse into a discarded future, before the band decided to fully merge with the machines they would eventually master.
Key track: Ruckzuck
7. Neil Young Trans (1982)
The giants of the Seventies adapted to the Eighties in remarkably different ways, and Neil Young’s Trans (1982) stands as one of the most radical reinventions. Abandoning his signature folk-rock guitar for synthesizers, vocoders, and electronic textures, Young crafted a futuristic, almost alien sound influenced by Kraftwerk and the burgeoning electronic scene.
Songs pulsate with mechanized rhythms, robotic vocals, and shimmering synthetic tones, creating an emotionally detached yet oddly compelling atmosphere. Fans expecting the plaintive acoustic guitar and raw vocal delivery of classic Young were bewildered, making the album one of his most divisive. Yet beneath its technological veneer lies an undercurrent of yearning and humanity, particularly in tracks inspired by his son’s speech difficulties.
Trans remains a fascinating experiment, an audacious leap into uncharted musical territory that continues to intrigue and challenge listeners decades later.
Key track: Computer Age showcases vocoder-driven vocals, robotic rhythms, and Young’s full dive into electronic experimentation.
8. The Beach Boys Smile (1967)
Smiley Smile stands apart in the Beach Boys’ catalogue as a haunting, intimate shadow of the abandoned Smile project. Recorded quickly at Brian Wilson’s home studio, it strips away lush orchestrations in favor of sparse, minimalist arrangements. The result is stoned, skeletal, and oddly unsettling – a curious blend of whimsy, eeriness, and domestic immediacy. Its experimental textures and off-kilter harmonies make it unlike anything else the band ever released.
Key track: Vegetables
9. Lou Reed Metal Machine Music (1975)
The ultimate career-sabotage gesture, Lou Reed’s fifth solo album is a 64-minute assault of pure, unyielding guitar feedback. Devoid of melody, rhythm, or lyrics, it sits in stark defiance of his street-poet legacy. While critics initially branded it a contractual-obligation spite move, it has since become an avant-garde touchstone. It remains a staggering outlier that successfully alienated his glam-rock fanbase while accidentally inventing the foundation for industrial and noise music.
10. Marvin Gaye In Our Lifetime (1981)
Marvin Gaye’s final Motown release is a deeply paranoid, funk-driven obsession with the struggle between divinity and the flesh. Eschewing the smooth, romantic 'healing' of his earlier masterpieces, Gaye produced a dense, agitated wall of sound that reflected his crumbling personal life and tax exile. It is a restless, spiritually tortured outlier that lacks a conventional 'hit', opting instead for a hypnotic, groove-heavy descent into the artist’s fractured psyche.
Key track: Praise
11. Paul McCartney McCartney II (1980)
McCartney II (1980) stands as a striking outlier in Paul McCartney’s solo catalogue. Almost entirely home-recorded, embracing synthesizers, drum machines, and playful experimentation, its quirky, electronic textures and humorous, sometimes surreal lyrics contrast sharply with McCartney’s usual melodic rock and balladry, revealing a side of the Beatle unafraid to be strange and self-indulgent. 'Temporary Secretary' is equal parts hilarious and awful; 'Darkroom' is eerie, skittering synth-pop.
Key track: Coming Up
12. The Who The Who Sell Out (1967)
Merging rock, satire, and conceptual audacity, The Who Sell Out stands out as a daring outlier in the band’s discography. Unlike the raw, Mod-fuelled energy of My Generation, this album plays like a pirate radio broadcast, peppered with faux commercials, jingles, and sound effects. Pete Townshend’s songwriting oscillates between whimsical pastiche and sharp social commentary, while Roger Daltrey’s vocals provide a charismatic anchor amid the playful chaos.
The album’s theatricality, humour, and experimental structure make it a uniquely inventive chapter in The Who’s career, showing them willing to push beyond conventional rock frameworks.
Key track: I Can’t Explain transforms from a punchy hit single into a playful, concept-driven piece, exemplifying the album’s ability to blend accessibility with bold, inventive experimentation.
13. KISS Music from "The Elder" (1981)
In a pivot that nearly ended their career, KISS ditched the leather-and-fireworks party anthems for a medieval-themed concept album. Complete with orchestral arrangements, acoustic flutes, and a libretto about a 'chosen one', it was a catastrophic stylistic misfire. Fans were baffled by the band’s sudden desire for high-art respectability, and the record remains a legendary outlier: a symphonic fantasy epic from a group famous for singing about rock and roll all night.
Key track: A World Without Heroes
14. Pink Floyd The Final Cut (1983)
Effectively a Roger Waters solo project released under the Pink Floyd banner, this record abandoned the band’s signature 'space-rock' grandeur for stark, theatrical realism. Gone are the sprawling jams and David Gilmour’s soaring melodicism; in their place is an intimate, bitter, and intensely lyrical anti-war polemic. It is the only Floyd album where the music feels entirely subservient to the libretto, marking a grim, hushed finale to the band’s classic era.
Key track: The Fletcher Memorial Home
- Pink Floyd's elegy to a fallen star: why 'Wish You Were Here' endures, 50 years on
- ‘I Hate Pink Floyd’: the ten 1970s bands caught in punk’s crosshairs
15. Velvet Underground Loaded (1970)
After years of abrasive noise, feedback, and avant-garde experimentation, Lou Reed guided the Velvet Underground toward a more polished, accessible sound. Loaded delivered classics like 'Sweet Jane' and 'Rock & Roll', showcasing tight arrangements and radio-friendly production. Its pop sheen, commercial intent, and melodic focus set it apart from the band’s earlier, more challenging work, making it feel like a distinct entity – simultaneously a swan song and an outlier in their groundbreaking discography.
Key track: Sweet Jane
16. Soft Machine Third (1970)
British psychedelic oddballs Soft Machine made the leap into Canterbury jazz-fusion titans with this sprawling double LP. Four side-long tracks of avant-garde improvisation and jazz minimalism alienated rock fans, but cemented them as cult innovators. It’s radical, dense, and completely unlike their psych-pop debut – an uncompromising leap into another universe.
Key track: Moon in June
17. Radiohead Kid A (2000)
Kid A marks a seismic reinvention for Radiohead, abandoning the guitar-driven alt-rock of OK Computer in favour of electronics, ambient textures, and subtle jazz influences. Its fractured rhythms, abstract song structures, and haunting atmospheres shocked listeners and critics alike, making it feel more like an avant-garde art project than a conventional rock album. Even decades later, its radical departure from expectation cements Kid A as one of the band’s most daring and outlier works.
Key track: Idioteque
18. The Rolling Stones Their Satanic Majesties Request (1967)
Satanic Majesties is the Stones’ strange detour into full-blown psychedelia, a technicolor counterpart to Sgt. Pepper. Laden with swirling sitars, Mellotrons, and studio effects, it swapped swaggering blues-rock for cosmic whimsy. Critics slammed it as self-indulgent, and even the band later dismissed it. Yet its kaleidoscopic eccentricity makes it a singular artifact: the only time the Stones fully abandoned grit for trippy, otherworldly experimentation.
Key track: 2000 Light Years from Home
19. Pretty Things Parachute (1970)
Previously known for raw R&B grit, the Pretty Things swerved into lush psychedelia on S.F. Sorrow – but Parachute went further, blending art-rock textures with melancholic conceptual sweep. Praised by critics (even Rolling Stone compared it favourably to The Beatles), it baffled their fanbase. It stands apart as their most ambitious, yet least typical, record.
Key track: The Good Mr Square
20. Captain Beefheart and the Magic Band Bluejeans & Moonbeams (1974)
Known for the avant-garde polyrhythmic chaos of Trout Mask Replica, Captain Beefheart made a baffling attempt at commercial soft-rock and soulful balladry here. The result is so slick and uncharacteristically conventional that his hardcore followers famously dubbed this the 'Tragic Band' era. While his growling vocals remain, the smooth, session-musician backing creates a jarring dissonance, making it a fascinatingly 'normal' outlier in a career defined by deliberate, brilliant weirdness.
Key track: Observatory Crest
21. The Monkees Head (1968)
After years of bubblegum chart-toppers and a carefully constructed, clean-cut TV image, The Monkees completely upended expectations with Head.
Released in 1968 as the soundtrack to the equally surreal, Jack Nicholson–co-written film of the same name, the album abandoned conventional pop structures in favour of abstract sound collages, acid-drenched jams, and biting anti-pop satire. Tracks veered unpredictably between spoken word snippets, chaotic effects, and fractured melodies, reflecting the film’s absurdist, countercultural sensibilities.
Commercially, Head was a disaster: audiences expecting catchy singles were bewildered by its fractured, avant-garde approach. Yet artistically, it stands as one of the boldest statements in the Monkees’ discography, a daring, unpolished glimpse of a band asserting creative control and embracing the experimental freedoms of late-1960s psychedelia.
Today, Head is celebrated for its fearless originality, revealing a side of the Monkees that was utterly unlike anything else they ever recorded.
Key track: Porpoise Song. The album’s haunting, psychedelic centrepiece, it vividly captures the film’s surreal, acid-soaked atmosphere.
Pics Getty Images
