If not carefully nurtured, the fragile ecosystem within a band created by a set of personal dynamics can breakdown spectacularly. If you add brothers to the mix, the possibility of malfunction increases multifold. Brothers are competitive by nature, they often resolve their conflict with a fist – throw them into the band environment and you’re asking for trouble.
With many bands it’s the struggle for artistic control between the siblings that creates an unequal power dynamic. This in turn leads to a pressure cooker environment that eventually explodes. In other cases, the brothers simply hate each other’s guts and always have done.
1. The Kinks – Ray and Dave Davies

The Gallaghers are the young pretenders at the foot of the Davies’ brothers throne when it comes to inter-band fighting. Siblings Ray and Dave were the youngest children, and only boys, in a family of 10, so their volatile battle for attention was fierce for the two of them from the outset. The other catalyst was the stark difference in their personality types with Ray the introverted perfectionist and Dave the free-spirited wild man.
The most extreme example of the rivalry came on the occasion of Dave’s 50th birthday, when Ray crashed the party, jumped on the cake and proclaimed himself the true genius of The Kinks. Happy birthday bruv!
Key track: 'Hatred (A Duet)'
2. Creedence Clearwater Revival – John and Tom Fogerty

John and Tom Fogerty’s brotherly beef sprang out of the thorny subject of artistic control. Despite experiencing a hugely successful run of chart success, songwriter John fell out with the rest of the band and his record label for being perceived as too domineering.
Instead of putting on the expected display of sibling unity, Tom sided with his band mates, Stu Cook and Doug Clifford. This not only caused an inevitable flurry of lawsuits, but also started a family rift that would be never be fully reconciled before Tom’s death in 1990.
Key track: ‘Have You Ever Seen The Rain?’
3. Oasis – Noel and Liam Gallagher

After a hugely successful reunion tour with the promise of more to follow, peace has finally broken out in the Oasis camp. Brought up in a dysfunctional family home, the two brothers share a long history of feuding, often violent, that dates back way before the formation of the band. Serious fights include Liam hitting his older brother on the head with a tambourine while onstage in LA, and Noel doing something similar with a cricket bat some time later.
The band split in 2009 when Liam swung a guitar at Noel in an axe-like motion during an altercation backstage at a gig in Paris. The number of verbal insults the two have traded is far too long to go into any depth here, but Liam’s series of tweets comparing his elder brother to a potato live forever.
Key track: 'Acquiesce'
4. Bachman-Turner Overdrive – Randy, Robbie and Tim Bachman

Randy Bachman was asked to leave his first band the Guess Who after being told he was "a lunatic and a loser." Along with Fred Turner and his younger brothers, Robbie and Tim, he decided to give the rock’n’roll band another go, and so Bachman-Turner Overdrive were born. Tim didn’t last long after he repeatedly fell foul of strict Mormon Randy’s hugely impractical tour rule of ‘no drugs, no alcohol, and no premarital sex’.
When Randy suddenly left the band in 1977 the band continued without him using the BTO name, when Randy tried to revive the full name for his own use a legal war broke out. This led to a series of court cases and long-lasting family enstrangements. When the other brothers died to leave Randy as the last Bachman standing, he was quoted as saying, “Now they’re all gone. There’s no fight.”
Key track: 'Roll On Down The Highway'
5. Black Crowes – Chris and Rich Robinson

The sibling dynamic in the Black Crowes is a very similar one to that of Oasis, and tongues could not have been any further in cheek when the two bands called double-headlining set of dates in 2001 ‘The Tour Of Brotherly Love’. While the Robinson brothers flare-ups weren’t as regular or dramatic as the Gallaghers the tension was always never far from the surface. Rich once said, “Chris and I have one unwritten rule. We can’t hit each other in the face.”
It all boiled over in 2014 when Rich released a press statement announcing the end of the band. He claimed that Chris had not only asked for founding member and drummer Steve Gorman lose his band member status to become a salaried employee, but also for him to give up his equal share of the band. Chris later admitted it wasn’t exactly the most brotherly of suggestions.
Classic track: 'Remedy'
6. Kings Of Leon – Caleb, Nathan and Jared Followill

To add to the volatile mix of three brothers, Kings Of Leon can also add a cousin, Matthew. A documentary about the band released in 2011 revealed that Caleb and Nathan had been involved in physical brawls on a number of occasions, including the time Caleb suffered a dislocated shoulder during a massive fist-fight.
The band’s constant fighting boiled over when a clearly intoxicated Caleb walked off stage during a concert in Dallas. His unscripted exit had costly consequences and the band were forced to cancel the remaining 26 dates of their US tour - a lengthy hiatus followed.
Classic track: 'Molly's Chambers'
7. Jesus and Mary Chain – Jim and William Reid

In a recent biography, William Reid stated that the higher profile Oasis were the "Hollywood remake of our little indie film about sibling rivalry." There’s no doubting that the levels of animosity between the two Scottish brothers have been viciously high.
The one thing the two of them do agree on is that excessive drug use played its part in ramping up the volatility. Rumour has it that the first brotherly bust-up was sparked by a bowl of nuts, with William causing an argument with his sister-in-law for eating too many of them.
Classic track: 'Never Understand'
8. Scorpions – Rudolf and Michael Schenker

The ongoing toxic war of words between Scorpions founder Rudolf Schenker and his younger brother Michael has been many decades in the making. Michael, the more famous of the two, has accused his sibling as being an "abusive bully" and a "desperate wannabe" who copied his look and stole his songwriting credits.
Rudolf is more measured, describing his brother as someone who is not cut out to be a permanent member of a band. It’s unlikely they’ll be getting back onstage with each other any time soon.
Classic track: 'Rock You Like A Hurricane'
9. The Allman Brothers – Duane and Gregg Allman

The competition between Duane and Gregg started as soon as the former picked up a guitar. To put an end to the bickering Mama Allman bought them both a guitar, the story goes that Duane was given a Gibson and Gregg received a Fender.
- The eerie coincidence that haunted one of rock's great American bands
- From Neil Young to Jimmy Page, we name the greatest guitarist in every rock genre
During the time they spent together in the band the sibling rivalry was intense, driving them both to creative heights, but not without the psychic trauma that comes with it. When Gregg was on the verge of going to the Vietnam war it was his domineering old brother that persuaded him to shoot himself in the foot to avoid getting drafted.
Classic track: 'Whipping Post'
10. Dire Straits – Mark and David Knopfler

Brothers Mark and David Knopfler were co-founders of Dire Straits, but the pressures of being in a band together split them apart. An unequal power dynamic within the band saw primary songwriter Mark assume leadership, pushing David increasingly to the sidelines.
David walked out of the band during the recording of third album, Making Movies. Mark’s response was to re-record his brother’s guitar parts and leave him uncredited. The two of them cut off relationships after the incident, no longer brothers in arms.
Classic track: 'Sultans Of Swing'
11. Everly Brothers – Phil and Don Everly

For a couple whose stock-in-trade was singing in harmony, the personal relationship between the two brothers was spectacularly unharmonious. Phil was quoted as saying the friction between them was there "from day one from birth." Both brothers had their problems with substance abuse from early on in their long, volatile career.
Breaking point was reached onstage during a performance in California in 1973. An argument broke out over an intoxicated Don’s inability to remember the lyrics to songs.
Phil smashed his guitar and walked off, but not before telling the crowd he was done being an Everly Brother. Don, now on stage alone, then cheerily announced, “The Everly Brothers died ten years ago.”
Classic track: 'Bye Bye Love'
All pics Getty Images.
Top image Liam and Noel Gallagher of Oasis, 1995


