History is littered with brilliant bands who, at the height of their powers or the depths of a mid-life crisis, made choices that left fans and critics scratching their heads. From genre-hopping disasters to baffling career pivots, here are 17 times the greats took a very strange turn.
1. The Beatles open The Apple Boutique, 1967
On 5 December 1967, in a move of peak psychedelic idealism, the Beatles opened a retail store in London intended to be a 'beautiful place where beautiful people can buy beautiful things'. They rejected traditional business logic, letting friends take whatever they wanted and refusing to stop shoplifters because it felt too corporate to call the police.
The interior was a kaleidoscope of expensive chaos, but the management was nonexistent. After losing a fortune, the band closed the doors just eight months later, giving the remaining stock away for free. It proved that while the Fab Four could revolutionize music, they were perhaps not so gifted at building a retail empire.
2. Pink Floyd fire Rick Wright, 1979
During the tense sessions for Pink Floyd's ambitious 1979 concept album The Wall, Roger Waters grew increasingly frustrated with founding keyboardist Richard Wright, eventually firing him for a perceived lack of contribution. In a surreal twist of logic, Waters then hired Wright back as a salaried session musician for the live tour.
Because the stage production was so massive and expensive, the tour actually lost money for the three official members of the band. Wright, however, was the only person who walked away with a profit because his salary was guaranteed. It was a cold, calculated move by Waters that accidentally rewarded the man he was trying to punish.
3. Emerson, Lake & Palmer drag an orchestra on tour, 1977
In an era of excess, those none-more-excessive prog rockers ELP decided to take their progressive rock to its logical, bank-breaking conclusion by touring with a full 70-piece orchestra. The logistical nightmare was staggering, with costs so high they were facing huge financial challenges within weeks.
They were forced to fire the entire orchestra mid-tour and continue as a simple trio just to afford to keep the tour running. It was a move of pure hubris that illustrated the massive disconnect between the band's artistic ambitions and the financial reality of the late seventies touring circuit.
4. Gentle Giant pretend to be punks, 1977
So, you're one of the most complex and inventive progressive rock bands in history. All well and good. But now it's 1977 and the UK has dived headlong into punk. What's a progger to do? Why, play the punks at their own game, of course. Enter the amusingly titled 'Betcha Thought We Couldn't Do It', from the band's 1977 album The Missing Piece.
Gentle Giant was a band capable of multi-part vocal counterpoint and 15/8 time signatures, so hearing them try to sound 'street' was an absurd stylistic mismatch. The song was meant to be a defiant statement to critics who called them over-educated, but hearing conservatory-trained virtuosos simulate amateurish aggression was unintentionally hilarious. It remains a fascinating example of a band so talented they forgot that punk is about an attitude you can't actually study or rehearse.
5. Fleetwood Mac sack Lindsey Buckingham, 2018
Decades after the Rumours drama had supposedly been laid to rest, the band made the shocking decision to fire their chief architect. The split reportedly stemmed from a disagreement over tour dates and an accusation that Buckingham had smirked during a speech by Stevie Nicks at a benefit gala.
For a band that had survived affairs and addiction, being broken apart by a perceived facial expression seemed petty. Replacing a visionary guitarist with Mike Campbell and Neil Finn allowed the stadium tours to continue, but it fundamentally severed the band’s creative heart and ended the most successful era of their history.
6. Lou Reed makes Metal Machine Music, 1975
Following the massive commercial success of Sally Can't Dance, Reed walked into a studio and recorded over an hour of screeching guitar feedback and electronic drone. There were no songs, no lyrics, and no rhythm. While some avant-garde critics now hail it as a prophetic birth of industrial noise, his label saw it as a literal contractual middle finger designed to end his deal.
For the average fan who bought it expecting 'Walk on the Wild Side', Metal Machine Music was an unlistenable betrayal. Reed later claimed he didn't even expect anyone to listen to the whole thing, making it one of rock's boldest pranks.
7. Genesis: the drummer grabs the mic, 1975
When Peter Gabriel departed in 1975, Genesis became a ship without a captain. They auditioned hundreds of vocalists, from the obscure to the established, yet found no one who captured the band's eccentric spirit. In a move born of sheer desperation, they allowed their drummer, Phil Collins, to step up to the microphone.
At the time, the idea was widely mocked; drummers were supposed to stay in the back, not lead the show. However, the gamble didn't just save the band: it transformed them from a niche prog-rock act into a global pop powerhouse, launching one of the biggest commercial juggernauts of the eighties.
8. Van Halen take Extreme measures, 1996
After the successful but acrimonious eras of David Lee Roth and Sammy Hagar, Eddie Van Halen made the baffling choice to hire Gary Cherone, the frontman of Extreme. On paper, Cherone was a talented singer, but the chemistry was nonexistent. The resulting album, Van Halen III, featured awkward, sprawling arrangements and lyrics that felt entirely out of place for a band synonymous with the ultimate California party.
Fans recoiled from the new sound, and the partnership dissolved quickly. It remains a strange footnote in rock history, proving that even a legendary guitar hero needs a singer who actually fits the band's DNA.
9. Metallica and Lou Reed fail to synergise, 2011
On paper, a meeting between the kings of thrash and the godfather of punk seemed like an interesting experiment. In reality, Lulu was a confusing, abrasive collection of songs that merged Metallica’s heavy riffs with Reed’s rambling, spoken-word poetry about a tragic play from 1913. The band defended the project as a creative exercise, but the backlash was immense. It remains one of the most divisive records in modern music, a bizarre moment where two legends collided and produced something that neither fan base truly understood.
10. David Bowie: the Tin Machine Era, 1989
After a decade as a solo superstar, David Bowie decided he was bored with being a pop icon. He formed Tin Machine, a noisy, democratic hard-rock quartet where he insisted on being just one of the guys. He even refused to do solo interviews and split the songwriting royalties equally.
It was a noble attempt to find creative humility, but the music was often abrasive and lacked the melodic genius fans expected. Most people found the 'ego-check' dull, and by the early nineties, Bowie realized that the world really just wanted him to be David Bowie again.
11. The Clash fire Mick Jones and go all '80s, 1983
After The Clash's frontman Joe Strummer sacked lead guitarist and co-songwriter Mick Jones, he tried to prove that he was the true heart of the band. Encouraged by manager Bernie Rhodes, Strummer attempted to create a raw punk record but utilized 1980s synthesizers and programmed drum machines.
It was a catastrophic misunderstanding of what made The Clash special and one of the worst albums by great bands. The human chemistry was replaced by a cold, muddy production that sounded like a parody of their earlier work. It remains a painful stain on a near-perfect legacy, serving as a warning that even the most principled punk bands can lose their way without their creative foils.
12. Billy Idol: Cyberpunk, 1993
In the early nineties, Billy Idol became obsessed with the burgeoning cyberpunk subculture and the potential of digital recording. He spent a fortune attempting to reinvent himself as a high-tech visionary, recording an entire album on a Macintosh computer and including a floppy disk with some editions. Unfortunately, Idol was a few years too early for the technology to be seamless and a decade too late for his brand of stadium-rock to feel cutting-edge. The record felt dated the moment it hit the shelves, stalling his career and proving that an image based on the future is the easiest one to get wrong.
13. The Rolling Stones try psychedelia, 1967
By 1967, the pressure to compete with the Beatles was immense. The Stones, traditionally hardened R&B purists, felt forced to adopt the flowery language of the psychedelic era. The result was the Satanic Majesties album, a cluttered, drug-addled experiment that traded their usual grit for flutes, sound effects, and rambling jams.
It felt like a costume that didn't fit. While tracks like 2000 Light Years from Home are now cult favourites, at the time the record was seen as a desperate attempt to join a parade they didn't belong in. They quickly abandoned the beads and incense for the rootsy, dangerous swagger of Beggars Banquet and embarked on one of rock's greatest album runs.
14. Creedence Clearwater Revival try democracy, 1972
After years of John Fogerty’s autocratic but highly successful leadership, in 1972 the Creedence frontman finally yielded to his bandmates' demands for equal songwriting and singing duties. Alas, it was a 'be careful what you wish for' moment. The resulting album, Mardi Gras, was so poorly written and performed that the band imploded immediately after its release. Fogerty, perhaps smugly, later called it the worst album he’d ever heard. By trying to be fair to everyone's ego, Creedence destroyed the very thing that made them one of America's greatest hit machines.
15. Led Zeppelin say no to singles
In a move that flew in the face of all music industry logic, Led Zeppelin often refused to release their most popular songs as singles. This included the legendary 'Stairway to Heaven', which never officially charted as a 45rpm record despite being the most played song in radio history. Their goal was to engage fans with the entire album, viewing the LP as a complete work of art rather than a collection of hits. It was a high-stakes gamble that worked brilliantly, making Led Zeppelin IV a massive seller, but it remains a bold defiance of the industry's hit-driven model.
16. Guns N' Roses release two double albums at once, 1991
At the peak of their fame, Guns N' Roses decided that one album wasn't enough to contain their ambition. They released the two double LPs Use Your Illusion I and II on the very same day. It was a move of pure hubris that forced fans to pay double or choose between their favourites.
While both albums were huge successes (and we'll take II by a whisker), the sheer amount of filler and orchestral bloat signalled the beginning of the internal fractures that would eventually destroy the band. It was the moment they stopped being a lean rock band and started becoming a sprawling, uncontrollable corporation.
17. Elvis Costello goes country, 1981
At the height of his fame as the angry young man of New Wave, Costello made a sharp left turn. He flew to Nashville to record an album of traditional country covers with legendary producer Billy Sherrill. This massive genre-whiplash left his skinny-tie-wearing fans completely confused.
While the record eventually earned respect for its sincerity and Costello's deep knowledge of the genre, at the time it felt like a deliberate act of career sabotage. It was a brave choice that proved Costello was more interested in his own musical education than maintaining a consistent public image.
Pics Getty Images
